The Divine Right of Capital – A Summary

The Divine Right of Capital

 

Marjorie Kelly’s The Divine Right of Capital is one of those mind-bending books that deserves to be read by a large audience. It tells a behind-the-scenes story of capitalism that we don’t often hear; one that shows how our preoccupation with shareholder “primacy” distorts capitalism in ways that generate serious harm for society and the planet. Kelly shows how our current problems with capitalism are not necessarily intrinsic to market forces or even capitalism itself, but to the particular version of it that we have today.

In this brave book, Kelly highlights the historical roots of our current system and its ties to feudalism, and then lays out a set of prescriptions for rethinking how corporations actually could work.

To help me digest this important book, I summarized each chapter, and in the hope of encouraging readers of this blog to read the book yourselves, I’m sharing these chapter-by-chapter overviews here on my blog – with the permission of the author.

Below are the 12 principles Kelly outlines in the book, with links to detailed summaries of each chapter:

Chapter 1: The Sacred Texts

The Principle of Worldview: In the worldview of corporate financial statements, the aim is to pay stockholders as much as possible, and employees as little as possible.

Chapter 2: Lords of the Earth

The Principle of Privilege: Stockholders claim wealth they do little to create, much as nobles claimed privilege they did not earn.

Chapter 3: The Corporation as Feudal Estate

The Principle of Property: Like a feudal estate, a corporation is considered a piece of property — not a human community — so it can be owned and sold by the propertied class.

Chapter 4: Only the Propertied Class Votes

The Principle of Governance: Corporations function with an aristocratic governance structure, where members of the propertied class alone may vote.

Chapter 5: Liberty for Me, Not for Thee

The Principle of Liberty: Corporate capitalism embraces a predemocratic concept of liberty reserved for property holders, which thrives by restricting the liberty of employees and the community.

Chapter 6: Wealth Reigns

The Principle of Sovereignty: Corporations assert that they are private and the free market will self-regulate, much as feudal barons asserted a sovereignty independent of the Crown.

Chapter 7: Waking Up

The Principle of Enlightenment: Because all persons are created equal, the economic rights of employees and the community are equal to those of capital owners.

Chapter 8: Emerging Property Rights

The Principle of Equality: Under market principles, wealth does not legitimately belong only to stockholders. Corporate wealth belongs to those who create it, and community wealth belongs to all.

Chapter 9: Protecting the Common Welfare

The Principle of the Public Good: As semipublic governments, public corporations are more than pieces of property or private contracts. They have a responsibility to the public good.

Chapter 10: New Citizens in Corporate Governance

The Principle of Democracy: The corporation is a human community, and like the larger community of which it is a part, it is best governed democratically.

Chapter 11: Corporations Are Not Persons

The Principle of Justice: In keeping with equal treatment of persons before the law, the wealthy may not claim greater rights than others, and corporations may not claim the rights of persons.

Chapter 12: A Little Rebellion

The Principle of (r)Evolution: As it is the right of the people to alter or abolish government, it is the right of the people to alter or abolish corporations that now govern the world.

 

The Divine Right of Capital: Chapter 1

Chapter 1: The Sacred Texts The Principle of Worldview: In the worldview of corporate financial statements, the aim is to pay stockholders as much as possible, and employees as little as possible. All societies have worldviews, the “unconscious mental habits” we use to make sense of the world – so deep, so pervasive as to be invisible. …

View page »

The Divine Right of Capital: Chapter 10

Chapter 10: New Citizens in Corporate Governance The Principle of Democracy: The corporation is a human community, and like the larger community of which it is a part, it is best governed democratically. In rethinking the corporation to be accountable to a broader set of stakeholders, it is important to note that employees are internal …

View page »

The Divine Right of Capital: Chapter 11

Chapter 11: Corporations Are Not Persons The Principle of Justice: In keeping with equal treatment of persons before the law, the wealthy may not claim greater rights than others, and corporations may not claim the rights of persons. Implementing economic democracy will require working through the political and judicial process in order to free our legal machinery …

View page »

The Divine Right of Capital: Chapter 12

Chapter 12: A Little Rebellion The Principle of (r)Evolution: As it is the right of the people to alter or abolish government, it is the right of the people to alter or abolish corporations that now govern the world. Thomas Jefferson once wrote, “A little rebellion now and then is a good thing, & as …

View page »

The Divine Right of Capital: Chapter 2

Chapter 2: Lords of the Earth The Principle of Privilege: Stockholders claim wealth they do little to create, much as nobles claimed privilege they did not earn. “If equality under the law is the hallmark of democracy, privilege sanctioned by law is the hallmark of aristocracy.” Just as feudal lords extracted wealth from serfs on …

View page »

The Divine Right of Capital: Chapter 3

Chapter 3: The Corporation as Feudal Estate The Principle of Property: Like a feudal estate, a corporation is considered a piece of property — not a human community — so it can be owned and sold by the propertied class. The source of stockholder privilege is ownership. Today we assume that 1) the corporation is …

View page »

The Divine Right of Capital: Chapter 4

Chapter 4: Only the Propertied Class Votes The Principle of Governance: Corporations function with an aristocratic governance structure, where members of the propertied class alone may vote. Stockholders reign supreme in corporate governance. In theory, the boards of directors are elected by shareholders, but in reality they are handpicked by the CEO and the existing …

View page »

The Divine Right of Capital: Chapter 5

Chapter 5: Liberty for Me, Not for Thee The Principle of Liberty: Corporate capitalism embraces a predemocratic concept of liberty reserved for property holders, which thrives by restricting the liberty of employees and the community. When wealth interests seek government protection, we’re told that property rights are vital to a free market. When the community …

View page »

The Divine Right of Capital: Chapter 6

Chapter 6: Wealth Reigns The Principle of Sovereignty: Corporations assert that they are private and the free market will self-regulate, much as feudal barons asserted a sovereignty independent of the Crown. Economic sovereignty trumps political sovereignty in the corporation. Stockholders are sovereign because they believe they are the corporation, much as King Louis XIV believed …

View page »

The Divine Right of Capital: Chapter 7

Chapter 7: Waking Up The Principle of Enlightenment: Because all persons are created equal, the economic rights of employees and the community are equal to those of capital owners. We have an old model of the corporation that equates it with a tangible object like a railroad or factory. This was more true in capitalism’s …

View page »

The Divine Right of Capital: Chapter 8

Chapter 8: Emerging Property Rights The Principle of Equality: Under market principles, wealth does not legitimately belong only to stockholders. Corporate wealth belongs to those who create it, and community wealth belongs to all. Thomas Paine’s Common Sense is widely credited with building public resolve for America’s independence from England. Pain started that famous document …

View page »

The Divine Right of Capital: Chapter 9

Chapter 9: Protecting the Common Welfare The Principle of the Public Good: As semipublic governments, public corporations are more than pieces of property or private contracts. They have a responsibility to the public good. Publicly traded corporations have their hands tied when it comes to truly acting in accordance with the public good. Concern for …

View page »